Managing staff performance

Advantages of performance appraisals


The advantages of a good appraisal system are that it will:

  • help you to assess your staff against defined objectives
  • give you the chance to give constructive feedback and to praise staff for their good work
  • allow you to define medium and long term objectives for your employees

It also offers the opportunity to:

  • address any problems
  • discuss apparent areas for development
  • find solutions, such as offering training
  • identify better ways to carry out tasks

Key elements of an effective appraisal system

There are four key elements in a good performance and appraisal system:

  • set objectives for the incoming year
  • monitor performance against objectives for the previous year - giving feedback which will help staff to improve if you think they aren't performing as required
  • carry out the appraisal (should include identifying any training needs to assist with meeting the incoming year's objectives)
  • provide rewards/remedies

How often should appraisals happen?

Many businesses carry out an appraisal after a set period of time for new employees or those who have changed jobs within the company. After that, formal appraisal meetings once or twice a year may be enough. If it's twice a year, one option is that the first of the two appraisals is an 'interim appraisal' looking at objectives and/or competencies.

It is important that you deal with issues of poor performance as part of your ongoing day to day management ie you should never leave this discussion until the annual or bi-annual appraisal meeting.

Get it right from the start

A performance system will work only if you plan and implement it properly:

  • make sure that you know what an employee's job involves - read their job description
  • keep it simple - this will save you time and money
  • use a standard format for your appraisal forms
  • make sure managers are committed to the appraisal process and they know what each employee will be expected to achieve
  • discuss what is proposed with employees, or unions if appropriate, before you implement an appraisal system

If you have an information and consultation agreement in place, you have a duty to inform and consult employees or their representatives on substantial changes to work, organisation or contractual relations. This includes the introduction of a new appraisal system.

Make sure you tell your employees about it in writing and include it in any new starter information packs.

Read more on how to inform and consult your employees.